A Millennium Bridge moment
 

Dental News
Article detail

See the following article detail about

A Millennium Bridge moment

0845 527 9810

Article details for

A Millennium Bridge moment

 

A Millennium Bridge moment

Kevin Lewis ponders to what extent the government is out of step with public – and the profession's – opinion...

You probably remember that awkward moment when the Millennium Bridge across the Thames got a touch of the wobbles. Its architects (with or without the input of any associated structural engineers) had not bargained for the risk that lots of people might want to walk across the bridge at the same time, let alone in unison. Riverdance it wasn't – but it could so easily have been (in another sense) if they hadn't closed the bridge while a rethink took place.

And then there's that ‘strange but true' story about the earth being knocked out of its orbit if everyone on the planet jumped up and down at the same moment in time. Same principle, no doubt, although I am tempted to wonder whether it depends upon where everyone is on the surface of the planet at the time they do it. On the law of averages, the short answer is probably ‘China'.

Would the same principle apply, you might ask, if enough people shook their heads and took in a sharp intake of breath at the same moment? Obviously not – because I can't have been alone in
doing precisely that when I first read the story about Linda O'Boyle, a former healthcare professional herself, and married to a former NHS manager, who died after being denied NHS cancer care by Southend University Hospital NHS Foundation Trust. This was because she had elected to pay privately for a drug that would double her chance of survival and/or prolong her life.

Group action
A group action is currently being taken on behalf of six patients in this kind of situation and it could end up with a Judicial Review which would test the legality of the policy. NHS managers point out that the cost of the drugs themselves (drugs like Avastin, Sutent etc) are only one part of the overall cost of care and reatment for these patients. The drug needs to be administered in a hospital bed which has to be paid for, and administered by NHS staff whose salaries need to be met, and provided alongside other tests, investigations and treatments that can cost £100,000 or more a year once everything is added up.

For the majority of NHS Trusts, and for the Department of Health, it is a non-negotiable philosophical principle. Indeed, Alan Johnson, the Secretary of State for Health, stood on the floor of the House and stated that it was ‘a founding principle of the NHS' that ‘someone is either a private patient or an NHS patient'. But reading the details of the cases, and the impact on real people, with real emotions, it all seemed so unfair, and the arguments so obvious. I then read the persuasive counter-argument about how unfair and sensitive it would be on an NHS ward, if one patient was receiving a drug (albeit at their own expense) that doubled their prospects of survival, while the patient in the next door bed was being denied that drug. How difficult would it be for the nurses and others who were administering the treatment, caring for the patients and answering their questions? Clearly, the argument is not quite as straightforward as it seems at first sight.

Principles
Eminent Senior Counsel have gone on the record as saying that while it might be a ‘founding principle' or a philosophical tenet at the NHS that you can't mix NHS and private care, it is certainly not the law, and should not be quoted or treated as such. It was a founding principle of the NHS that it would be free to all at the point of delivery, but that was before dental and prescription charges (and other charges) changed all that. And how ‘safe' is the ‘no mixing of NHS and private' rule, in the face of all the Private Finance initiatives (PFIs) that have built so many hospitals and other facilities around the country, the specific regulatory provision to mix NHS and private dentistry, and the Health Minister Ben Bradshaw's recent announcement that private sector senior managers will soon be employed as consultants by the NHS to turn around failing NHS hospitals, because of the added skills and competencies that they might bring to the challenge?

One senses, however, that the government is alarmingly out of step with public opinion, and with a significant amount (but not all) of opinion within the medical and nursing professions. A recent ICM poll found that more than a fifth of those sampled would be willing to pay £10,000 or more to ‘top-up' their NHS care if they were faced with a life-threatening condition. Just under a quarter would pay up to £15,000. Significantly, perhaps, those in their 20s and 30s were more likely to favour the ability to top-up NHS care, while those in retirement and/or on fixed incomes were more likely to believe that
everything should be funded by the state.

The difficulty with the government is that in clinging so trenchantly to one of its most precious principles (the elimination of any inequalities in healthcare), it finds itself abandoning another (patient choice) – unless of course ‘die sooner, or die later' is an example of choice.

Tipping point
But if 93% of people (accepting for a moment the ICM poll, which for the record was commissioned by the ‘Doctors for Reform' Lobby Group) really do think that they should be free to use their after-tax income to purchase private healthcare for themselves, without foregoing their right to receive NHS treatment in return for the taxes and National Insurance contributions that they have already paid, then we must be getting close to a tipping point.

And if all those people jumped up and down in anger and frustration when the government would rather see people die than sacrifice a ‘founding principle', would it be sufficient to deflect the Earth from its orbit?

Probably not, but the strength of protests following the 10p tax rate debacle did prove enough to deflect the government from its intended course, and humble pie was definitely on the dinner menu in Ward 10. And to be honest, there is a lot of jumping up and down left to come in this latest production of a Whitehall farce. Fuel protests, the dire plight of the British Agricultural Industries at a time when food prices to the consumer are sky high, the credit crunch... anyone for a wobble?

 Posted on : Tue 17th - Jun - 2008

 

Call Dental Support UK

Premium IT Support

  • All Servers & workstations covered..
  • Saturday Cover INCLUDED.
  • Telephone support.
  • Remote support.
  • 4 hour on-site Server response.
  • System monitoring.
  • Network monitoring and security.
  • Anti-Virus & Application updates.
  • Unlimited Remote Server Data backup.
  • Loan equipment on hardware failure.
  • Reduced rates for PC parts supply & installations.

No matter how big
your practice you
pay the same
price!!


ONLY

Click here for more info
Dental News Archives 2018

November - 2018
October - 2018
September - 2018
August - 2018
July - 2018
June - 2018
May - 2018
April - 2018
March - 2018
February - 2018
January - 2018

Dental News Archives 2017

December - 2017
November - 2017
October - 2017
September - 2017
August - 2017
July - 2017
June - 2017
May - 2017
April - 2017
March - 2017
February - 2017
January - 2017

Dental News Archives 2016

December - 2016
November - 2016
October - 2016
September - 2016
August - 2016
July - 2016
June - 2016
May - 2016
April - 2016
March - 2016
February - 2016
January - 2016

Dental News Archives 2015

December - 2015
November - 2015
October - 2015
September - 2015
August - 2015
July - 2015
June - 2015
May - 2015
April - 2015
March - 2015
February - 2015
January - 2015

Dental News Archives 2014

December - 2014
November - 2014
October - 2014
September - 2014
August - 2014
July - 2014
June - 2014
May - 2014
April - 2014
March - 2014
February - 2014
January - 2014

Dental News Archives 2013

December - 2013
November - 2013
October - 2013
September - 2013
August - 2013
July - 2013
June - 2013
May - 2013
April - 2013
March - 2013
February - 2013
January - 2013

Dental News Archives 2012

December - 2012
November - 2012
October - 2012
September - 2012
August - 2012
July - 2012
June - 2012
May - 2012
April - 2012
March - 2012
February - 2012
January - 2012

Dental News Archives 2011

January - 2011
February - 2011
March - 2011
April - 2011
May - 2011
June - 2011
July - 2011
August - 2011
September - 2011
October - 2011
November - 2011
December - 2011

Dental News Archives 2010

December - 2010
November - 2010
October - 2010
September - 2010
August - 2010
July - 2010
June - 2010
May - 2010
April - 2010
March - 2010
February - 2010
January - 2010

Dental News Archives 2009

December - 2009
November - 2009
October - 2009
September - 2009
August - 2009
July - 2009
June - 2009
May - 2009
April - 2009
March - 2009
February - 2009
January - 2009

Dental News Archives 2008

December - 2008
November - 2008
October - 2008
September - 2008
August - 2008
July - 2008
June - 2008
May - 2008
April - 2008
March - 2008
February - 2008
January - 2008

Dental News Archives 2007

December - 2007
November - 2007
October - 2007
September - 2007
August - 2007
July - 2007
June - 2007
May - 2007
April - 2007
March - 2007
February - 2007
January - 2007

Dental News Archives 2006

December - 2006
November - 2006
October - 2006
September - 2006
August - 2006
July - 2006
June - 2006
May - 2006
April - 2006
March - 2006
February - 2006
January - 2006

Dental News Archives 2005

December - 2005
November - 2005
October - 2005
September - 2005
August - 2005
July - 2005
June - 2005
May - 2005

hide toolbar
Would you like weekly updates on our latest offers? If so enter your email :
Quick Remote Dental Support