Kevin Lewis column
 

Dental News
Article detail

See the following article detail about

Kevin Lewis column

0845 527 9810

Article details for

Kevin Lewis column

 

Kevin Lewis column

Kevin Lewis looks at who has been stealing the show as dentistry returns to the media spotlight.

 

War of words

 

Nobody will have failed to notice that the media's summer ‘silly season' is over, health is squarely back on the menu, and dentistry has started to reappear in the media. In recent weeks it has mostly amounted to verbal sparring, and in fairness some of it has been pretty good, whether you agree with the sentiments or not. What I have found interesting, in fact, is that it is difficult to disagree with quite a lot of what had actually been said by any party, because the spinning and gliding would have been good enough to have satisfied Torvill & Dean's choreographer.

For example, Richard Daniels of the Dental Laboratories Association elegantly highlighted the massive drop in the volume of work being sent to dental laboratories since the new NHS contract was introduced. The distribution of the remaining work was also very different, with less complex crown and bridgework being done. Elsewhere it was stated that dentists were offering simpler and cheaper alternatives – acrylic dentures instead of chrome cobalt dentures, extractions instead of crowns, dentures instead of bridges.

Peter Ward (chief executive, BDA) was having none of it. The majority of practitioners, he reassured the public, could be relied upon to provide the treatment that was right for their patients – but he also made the point rather nicely that practitioners were working in the real world where income needed to exceed expenditure. The profession, he said, had been lumbered with a contract that nobody wanted, that was unfair and illogical in its design, and it was all the government's responsibility, not that of the dentists – who were simply trying to look after their patients and make the new contract work.

Enter Barry Cockroft (chief dental officer for England), who pointed out that a fee-per-item payment system encouraged intervention. Intervention – and lots of it – had been necessary and desirable in post-war 1948, but that was no longer the case. The dental health of the population had dramatically improved and NHS dentistry now needed a contract which could maintain and reinforce that improvement. He agreed that less dentistry was being provided – fewer, smaller courses of treatment – but this, he argued, had always been the master plan. The whole aim of the NHS reforms was to encourage dentists to do less interventive treatment, and that is precisely what has been happening. Stunned silence. Well, thank heavens for that, then. And there were we, foolishly thinking that it had all gone terribly wrong – when in fact, it had all gone wonderfully right.

What nobody was asking, however, was the million dollar question. Was too much dentistry being done under the fee-per-item NHS? If so, perhaps the new, reduced level of intervention was actually nearer to being in the best long-term interests of patients, than the ‘old' level. But who is going to tell the patients that were having all that treatment prior to April 2006 with the government's blessing?

Up and down
There is of course a ‘windfall' benefit of doing less treatment – lower lab fees, reduced consumption of dental materials etc – but what is a benefit to one person, is a disaster for another. What we are witnessing, as the new contract starts to bed down, is the gradual dislocation of the dental eco-system as we knew it.

How would you fancy being the owner of a large dental laboratory, facing a 50% drop in turnover? Or a specialist chrome cobalt laboratory (or specialist chrome technician) where stories abound of a reduction in throughput in the region of 80%-90%? There was a time when NHS dental practices were acquiring OPG machines as if they were about to go out of fashion. Well they certainly have now. And most dental wholesalers will confirm that far less of dentistry's ‘raw materials' are being purchased.

Just as the sales of bricks and other building materials is a fair measure of the buoyancy of the construction industry, these sales of dental materials are a useful measure of how much everyday dentistry is being done; even in the absence of the hard measures that once existed in Eastbourne. Another very obvious clue comes from comparing what dentists are buying in England and Wales, with what they are buying in Scotland and Northern Ireland, where fee-per-item still exists. If we are brutally honest, I think we are forced to concede that treatment patterns are strongly influenced by systems of remuneration. There is an abundance of evidence stretching back over many years to support this contention.

Prevention
Fee-per-item didn't encourage prevention and health promotion, and nor (I am sorry to say) does this contract. All the brave rhetoric of Options For Change in this connection is a distant memory, and that is a real tragedy, in my view. But it is also true that air rotors remove tooth tissue more effectively than caries ever will, and perhaps by providing some incentives to reach for the air rotor less often and to put it down sooner, we will be preserving more tooth tissue in other ways, after all. Come back Aubrey Sheiham – all is forgiven! You were right all along. Are you free for a TV appearance next Thursday?

It seems like only yesterday that the DPB's Dental Data Services Division was trumpeting list sizes and the amounts of treatment of all kinds that were being carried out by NHS practitioners. More (of both) were seen to be good news then, and politicians (of all persuasions) dined out and took credit from the numbers that we were producing for them.

This year's Alastair Campbell Memorial Award must surely go to Barry Cockcroft's response to the reporter that asked him whether he was concerned about the sharp reduction in the amount of treatment being provided. Not at all, it seems, because this was exactly what was always intended. Now that lists have been abolished, and ‘less' is apparently desirable, no doubt politicians will still be dining out and taking the credit for the reductions that we have facilitated? But don't get too excited just yet – the auditors and Treasury haven't had their say yet. Same money for less output? I don't think so. The war of words has only just begun.

 Posted on : Tue 25th - Sep - 2007

 

Call Dental Support UK

Premium IT Support

  • All Servers & workstations covered..
  • Saturday Cover INCLUDED.
  • Telephone support.
  • Remote support.
  • 4 hour on-site Server response.
  • System monitoring.
  • Network monitoring and security.
  • Anti-Virus & Application updates.
  • Unlimited Remote Server Data backup.
  • Loan equipment on hardware failure.
  • Reduced rates for PC parts supply & installations.

No matter how big
your practice you
pay the same
price!!


ONLY

Click here for more info
Dental News Archives 2018

August - 2018
July - 2018
June - 2018
May - 2018
April - 2018
March - 2018
February - 2018
January - 2018

Dental News Archives 2017

December - 2017
November - 2017
October - 2017
September - 2017
August - 2017
July - 2017
June - 2017
May - 2017
April - 2017
March - 2017
February - 2017
January - 2017

Dental News Archives 2016

December - 2016
November - 2016
October - 2016
September - 2016
August - 2016
July - 2016
June - 2016
May - 2016
April - 2016
March - 2016
February - 2016
January - 2016

Dental News Archives 2015

December - 2015
November - 2015
October - 2015
September - 2015
August - 2015
July - 2015
June - 2015
May - 2015
April - 2015
March - 2015
February - 2015
January - 2015

Dental News Archives 2014

December - 2014
November - 2014
October - 2014
September - 2014
August - 2014
July - 2014
June - 2014
May - 2014
April - 2014
March - 2014
February - 2014
January - 2014

Dental News Archives 2013

December - 2013
November - 2013
October - 2013
September - 2013
August - 2013
July - 2013
June - 2013
May - 2013
April - 2013
March - 2013
February - 2013
January - 2013

Dental News Archives 2012

December - 2012
November - 2012
October - 2012
September - 2012
August - 2012
July - 2012
June - 2012
May - 2012
April - 2012
March - 2012
February - 2012
January - 2012

Dental News Archives 2011

January - 2011
February - 2011
March - 2011
April - 2011
May - 2011
June - 2011
July - 2011
August - 2011
September - 2011
October - 2011
November - 2011
December - 2011

Dental News Archives 2010

December - 2010
November - 2010
October - 2010
September - 2010
August - 2010
July - 2010
June - 2010
May - 2010
April - 2010
March - 2010
February - 2010
January - 2010

Dental News Archives 2009

December - 2009
November - 2009
October - 2009
September - 2009
August - 2009
July - 2009
June - 2009
May - 2009
April - 2009
March - 2009
February - 2009
January - 2009

Dental News Archives 2008

December - 2008
November - 2008
October - 2008
September - 2008
August - 2008
July - 2008
June - 2008
May - 2008
April - 2008
March - 2008
February - 2008
January - 2008

Dental News Archives 2007

December - 2007
November - 2007
October - 2007
September - 2007
August - 2007
July - 2007
June - 2007
May - 2007
April - 2007
March - 2007
February - 2007
January - 2007

Dental News Archives 2006

December - 2006
November - 2006
October - 2006
September - 2006
August - 2006
July - 2006
June - 2006
May - 2006
April - 2006
March - 2006
February - 2006
January - 2006

Dental News Archives 2005

December - 2005
November - 2005
October - 2005
September - 2005
August - 2005
July - 2005
June - 2005
May - 2005

hide toolbar
Would you like weekly updates on our latest offers? If so enter your email :
Quick Remote Dental Support